UML’s double standards: Party pressures Deputy Speaker over letter, silent on Adhikari’s misconduct

Kathmandu, November 7 — Deputy Speaker Indira Rana Magar faced sharp political criticism after a letter she wrote to the US Embassy for interviews was made public a few months ago. The controversy escalated to the point where political parties were preparing to file an impeachment motion against her unless she resigned from her post.

The ruling parties, Nepali Congress (NC) and Communist Party of Nepal (Unified Marxist-Leninist) [CPN-UML], were at the forefront of the efforts to pressure Rana into resigning. The letter, which Rana wrote asking the US Embassy to reschedule interviews for five individuals in connection with the 67th session of the Commission on the Status of Women in the United States, was seen by the ruling parties as a violation of parliamentary norms and dignity. 

On February 26, 2023, Deputy Speaker Rana had written the letter, requesting the rescheduling of interviews for Upendra Gautam, Sushma Lama, Rajesh Lama Tamang, Sujan Gharti Magar, and Dhan Prasad Gurung. After the letter became public, NC and CPN-UML leaders claimed that if Rana did not resign, they would initiate impeachment proceedings. However, there were also claims that the letter had been used as a pretext for allegations of human trafficking, with some accusing her of abusing her position.

Despite the controversy surrounding her, the Deputy Speaker had written the letter to advance the interview dates, but the US Embassy had reportedly not registered the letter. Nevertheless, the opposition parties used this as a basis to accuse her of trying to facilitate human trafficking.

Meanwhile, a more serious issue has emerged within the CPN-UML, involving Lilaballabh Adhikari, the former Minister for Internal Affairs and Law of the Koshi Province. Adhikari, who resigned from his ministerial post, is now facing allegations of misusing his position for illegal activities, specifically for human trafficking.

On October 31, Adhikari traveled to Japan with three individuals without the necessary approvals from either the provincial or federal governments. They were later deported by Japan's immigration authorities, and Adhikari is accused of using his ministerial status to facilitate their travel illegally.

Though police have detained the three individuals who traveled with Adhikari, he has not been arrested yet. Even with such serious allegations, the CPN-UML has remained silent on the matter, which has drawn criticism within the party itself.

One senior leader of CPN-UML expressed surprise at the party's silence, stating that there should have been an immediate investigation and disciplinary action. "The party should have taken action quickly, but it seems to be in a state of inaction," said the leader. The leader also suggested that Adhikari might be trying to delay any consequences by stepping down from his ministerial post, but still holding onto his position as a Member of the Provincial Assembly and CPN-UML party member.

In response to the growing criticism, CPN-UML Secretary Yogesh Bhattarai acknowledged that no formal discussion has taken place within the party regarding Adhikari's conduct. He mentioned that the party leadership asked Adhikari to resign from his ministerial position, which he has already done. Bhattarai also stated that the issue would be discussed further in the party's Secretariat meeting.

Regarding legal procedures, Bhattarai added that Adhikari would have to address the issue personally and that the party would likely conduct an internal investigation if necessary.

'Even the Prime Minister can face disciplinary action'

Keshav Badal, the Chairman of CPN-UML’s Disciplinary Commission, made it clear that anyone within the party, regardless of their position, could face disciplinary action if they violate the party's code of conduct. Citing party regulations, Badal emphasized that anyone who goes against the party’s values, principles, or the decisions of the General Convention would be held accountable.

"Whether it is the Chairman, the Secretariat members, or anyone else, there is no exception when it comes to violating the party’s discipline," Badal said. He further urged the state agencies to investigate the incident thoroughly.

Badal also reminded party members of the importance of adhering to ethical conduct, stating that greed, especially for power, money, or sex, often leads to personal ruin. He appealed to all party leaders and workers to avoid falling into these temptations.

Regarding the specific case of Adhikari, Badal urged the relevant authorities to conduct a thorough investigation. He also suggested that if the allegations are confirmed, Adhikari’s party membership could be revoked, and he could face suspension or other disciplinary measures. A formal decision on the matter is expected during the CPN-UML Secretariat meeting on Saturday.

The party’s disciplinary regulations apply to all party members, including those in leadership positions, and violations of these rules will not be tolerated, Badal stressed.